Comfort Magazine #2: Patterns

Quilt by unknown maker, Thomas County Kansas Historical Society

Until very recently I'd have guessed the date on this quilt to be about 1880-1900. The Turkey red, the beautiful feather quilting---so 19th century. "Late in the 19th century" is indicated by the fading tan

leaves and stems, must once have been green but you often see greens fade to this dun-colored tan after 1880.

Where did she get the pattern?

Conventional Lily

Could it be from Comfort magazine which printed a photo of an almost identical

design in 1928?

1928?

Seems awfully late. But once I started looking at the applique designs published in Comfort in the 1920s I began to see a pattern so to speak. (See yesterday's post on Comfort here:

https://barbarabrackman.blogspot.com/2019/12/comfort-magazine-patterns.html )

The quilt was bought at a sale in Yadkin County,

North Carolina, dated by the able North Carolina team as around 1870. 

In 1923 the photo of the pattern was mailed to the magazine by Marie H. Carey who called it

Bleeding Heart and said she copied it from "an old Indiana quilt. Coloring: yellow, followed by red, then double green leaves, followed by yellow, topped with red heart-like pieces." The North Carolina quilt attributed to the family of Lola Taylor follows the color suggestions with the exception of the fugitive blue for green.

Now, this may be a question of chicken and egg superseding one another. Did Marie H. Carey photograph the Taylor family quilt? Or did the Taylor family make the quilt after finding the pattern in Comfort in 1923?

Comfort, June, 1928

Surprisingly Comfort, aimed at rural women, 

had the largest circulation of any U.S.

 magazine in the early 20th century.

I am afraid that I am now leaning towards the idea that the quilts were made after the patterns were published in the 1920s. You might notice my discomfort with these Comfort patterns. If....then... We've been dating these very traditional quilts very wrong.

Here's Lemon Lily or Cockscomb from my Encyclopedia of Applique among two other distinctive Comfort designs. 

My drawing is not great

and neither is Mildred Dickerson's from her Comfort scrapbook at the Quilt Research Center at the University of Nebraska Libraries. No date on either sketch. Thanks to Merikay Waldvogel for allowing me to photograph Mildred's Comfort files.

Here is what it is supposed to look like, I guess. Lemon Lily.

From an ebay auction. Apparently she had two dye lots of 

red ---one fast and one fugitive. I would not have dated this into the 1920s...

until now.

"Coxcomb variation quilt by Ellen Aycock Jones, ca. 1870s."

McKissick Museum, University of South Carolina

May be time for some revisionist history.

Just how old are these solid color quilts?

Update: Debby K sent this block she worked up into a small piece.

Flowering Almond from Mrs. M  M Mitchell in Tennessee in the 1920s.